February 25, 2014  |  An Auteurist History of Film
Peter Emanuel Goldman’s Echoes of Silence
Echoes of Silence. 1965. USA. Written, directed, and photographed by Peter Emmanuel Goldman

Echoes of Silence. 1965. USA. Written, directed, and photographed by Peter Emmanuel Goldman

These notes accompany screenings of Peter Emanuel Goldman’s Echoes of Silence on February 26, 27, and 28 in Theater 3.

As Peter Emanuel Goldman has graciously informed me, accounts of his death (as Mark Twain said of his own in 1897) have been greatly exaggerated. Once I got over some of my embarrassment, I began thinking about paraphrasing General Douglas MacArthur—something along the lines of “young auteurs never die, they just morph into international celebrities whose activities have ranged from playing for the French national champion baseball team to advising presidents.” Goldman, now based in Paris, seems to have forgiven me, but I doubt that I can persuade him to come back to New York and help the hapless Mets. He has written a novel, Last Metro to Bleecker Street, and perhaps we can grab him on a future book tour. (He previously published an autobiographical novel, Echoes of a Crying Floor.)

Long before I saw Echoes of Silence, I was intrigued by Goldman’s early break with the established film underground in New York and its high priest, Jonas Mekas. Mekas, then the film editor for The Village Voice, wrote his own column on the burgeoning avant-garde and brought Andrew Sarris in to write about those pesky commercial films. The soon-to-be creator of the Anthology Film Archives, Mekas, then as now, was a champion of Andy Warhol. In a letter to the Voice, Goldman depicted Mekas’s defense of Warhol’s Eat as an exercise in rationalizing “boring” movies, not the “pure cinema” that Mekas claimed it to be. At the risk of sacrilege, I must confess that I share many of Goldman’s sentiments, but I’m sure I can be written off as an addict of those pesky narratives. Of course, it is ultimately Mekas’s fault for putting Sarris in a place where he could be read by a long-time (but young and impressionable) moviegoer seeking distraction from academe.

Echoes of Silence (which is finally available on DVD, with Goldman’s Wheel of Ashes) was called by critic Henri Chapier “the most poignant film ever made about the profound despair of the young.” Susan Sontag designated Goldman as “the most exciting filmmaker in recent years.” The film shares some of Warhol’s traits, but, for me, there seems to be a planned sensibility at work here, whereas many of Warhol’s works seem to reflect a “director” who turned a switch on the camera and allowed his “actors” to offer whatever mindless chatter popped into their heads. Goldman’s film is, of course, without dialogue, but his images (some of them stills) capture New York scenes of the 1960s that remain indelible and hauntingly moving. They range from pickups at art museums or Greenwich Village coffee houses to pre-Stonewall gay encounters to pre-Disney-fication 42nd Street. There is a ghostliness that recalls F. W. Murnau’s sublime silents (see Faust and Sunrise in our upcoming April series The Aesthetics of Shadow, Part 2). Juxtapose these images with the decade of assassinations, Vietnam, and the Six Day War in which they were filmed, and one can’t help recalling the Bogart quote in Casablanca about problems of individuals under certain circumstances not “amounting to a hill of beans.”

The above reference to the Six Day War is poignant and pointed, since Goldman has directed much of his post-film career and life to championing the cause of Israel, and becoming, in his words, “Torah-observant.” He has, thus, traveled a long road since diverging from the denizens of the night depicted in Echoes of Silence. What might have been a long and illustrious career as a filmmaker gave way to another calling. It is, however, important to remember and salute the unique films that Goldman made, and to mourn (just a little) for those that might have been. In some sense, Peter Goldman has created a Salinger-esque gap in our medium.


I “hung out” with Peter, and his actors (Pierre Clementi and Juliet Berto) during the shooting of Wheels of Ashes in Paris in 1967-68. I was saddened to learn that both Pierre and Juliet died relatively young. And happy to know Peter is still around. My role during the shooting was to taking film shot each day to St. Cloud for development and to bring back the “rushes” to Peter for viewing. I would love to get in contact with Peter again after so many decades. Does anyone know his email?

great read, I’ve been scouring the web for information on this film and maker so thanks for tracking him down. I will be in Paris this summer making a 16mm film in the style of Jonas Mekas a la…. I wonder if I could get in contact with Peter through proxy of you Mr. Silver? I have included my email address, I hope you have some time to write me , I would very much like to connect one generation of american filmmaker with another!


I met with Peter today. His is looking well and I have to say meeting him for the first time in my life, not knowing about his past / career I was taken by his intellect and the beauty in himself.
Peter is very religious, I believe and I m not saying orthodox. Currently he has no computer by choice. But he does have a cell phone and I hope that I don’t make a mistake by sharing it with the people who care about him and try to reach him.
Kind regards

I knew Peter Emmanuel Goldman in the ’60s, Providence R.I. He lived for a short while in my apartment @ 115 N. Main St, he at Brown U, and I at RISD studying painting. I knew him during the pre-film maker years, before he went to NYC. I would like very much to speak with him again or simply be in contact.

I knew Peter many years ago–in the 60\’s. I was recently divorced from artist, Tim Saska, at the time and he knew me as Gwen Saska. I lived in the Village in NYC. He met me in Provincetown, Massachusetts, and followed me because he \”liked my legs\”. He took me out several times in NYC and finished \”Echoes of Silence\” when I knew him.
I have always wondered what happened to him. He was very unique and his specialness was apparent.

How would I go about getting a CD of Peter Goldman’s film, ECHOES OF SILENCE? Also, what is the fee?

I went to see Peter and his exhibit in Miami. It was special as is he. Although he didn’t remember me or my legs, we had a good visit and I am happy I made the effort. Our last encounter was briefly fifty-two years ago in Provincetown, Massachusetts.

I just came across your message and would like to let you know that we don’t have a CD of ‘Echoes of Silence’, but we do sell a DVD of the film here: You can order it directly from our site. There is even some bonus 8mm footage that Peter shot during the same era. Feel free to contact us if you have any further questions about the DVD.
Best Regards,

Met Peter when I was very young, in Greenwich Village, maybe 1965, would love to get in touch with him. Went out briefly with him.

Met Peter in 1965 in Greenwich Village, would love to speak with him. The number someone posted above is not a valid number

Leave a Comment

* required information

E-mail address*

Your comments*

Spam check*
Cri_151170 Please enter the text in the image.